Originally posted by nater Any reason not to use an older superzoom? I don't have a K-1, but I have used the Sigma 50-500mm f/4-6.3 EX APO RF, Tokina 24-200mm f/3.5-5.6 AT-X 242 AF, and Tamron 24-135mm f/3.5-5.6 AD Aspherical IF Macro SP AF (not quite a superzoom) successfully on my K-5. They should work on the K-1.
Main reasons is that those are older lenses not really made for digital, probably not as sharp, and also only available used which may not be in great condition.
I recently bought a Sigma 28-300 DG on Amazon for $60 that turned out to be defective. There are a few Tamron or Sigma 28-300 on ebay but mostly in Japan, and condition is not great in terms of dust.
I would like to get the best possible IQ, within the compromise parameters that a superzoom allows. And of course I already bought the Tamron 1.4x TC so that is a sunk cost.
Just not sure if older FF zoom will really provide better IQ than new APS-C zoom + TC in FF mode. I guess one would have to test both to be sure.
I guess the best / least compromise combo would be an APS-C Sigma 18-300 on a crop body with >16MP like the K-70 or K-P. But I generally prefer not to carry multiple cameras.
And of course buying one more body costs $$$. I'm still unemployed at the moment so I'm not buying any more lenses or bodies just yet, but it looks like I will be getting a job offer by the end of this week and I may resume my LBA soon after.
I think all of this doesn't make a lot of sense, though. Maybe I can just use my tiny Lumix GX85 with the 12-32 lens for the wide range. That is 24-64mm in 35mm equivalent.
And keep the Sigma 70-300mm on my K-1 II . That would cover the whole range I need.
It is two bodies, but the weight of the GX85 + lens is actually less than that of the Sigma 18-300 superzoom lens. And if course I already have it so no extra purchase necessary.
The GX85 can be easily handheld in one hand without neck strap also. Probably wouldn't hurt to get a wrist strap if I'm going to use two cameras. Still less convenient than just using one camera with one lens. GX85 doesn't take nearly as good pictures as the K-1 II. It uses a proprietary Li-On battery also which is annoying.
At least the K-30 can take AA . K-70 cannot. K-P cannot either, even with its grip.
All these options look like compromises. What I really want is a modern FF zoom for Pentax ...