Originally posted by jddwoods Did precision charge more than the price they quoted on their website? I checked their website and they quote a flat $212 to repair the DA 17-70. I would imagine mine would need the same repair as yours. On mine the SDM is dead. If the repair is $212, I would go ahead and repair mine but if the cost runs up much higher, then it remains a paperweight.
I'm in Canada, so I didn't send them to Precison but to Sun Camera which is the service center for Pentax in Canada. The repair was done under warranty... So, I can't tell how it would have cost or if the quote was respected.
Originally posted by jddwoods The German website photo zone.de (now optical limits) tested with the 17-70 and the 16-85 and liked both of them. It was not, however, a head to head comparison. As far as I have seen, and my own experience the optical performance of both is very good. My subjective impression is that the 16-85 is slightly sharper, especially 50mm and up, but both were really good.
At normal market price, the 16-85 should be the best choice since both lenses are fairly close in price. In fact, I spotted the deal on the 17-70 (300 $CDN ~ 225$US) when looking for the 16-85. At this price, the DA 17-70, brand new and covered by warranty was a much better deal! BTW, it's still available at this price at MacBain Camera...
---------- Post added 09-12-18 at 10:56 AM ----------
Originally posted by jddwoods The German website photo zone.de (now optical limits) tested with the 17-70 and the 16-85 and liked both of them.
Looking more closely at the Photozone results, I would even dare to say that both are amongst the best zooms of this kind, no matter the manufacturer or system... Canon, Nikon 16-85 both look slightly inferior as is the Sigma 17-70, Sony has a Zeiss 16-80 that looks excellent but in the dead A-mount and costing 1000$, Fuji actually has nothing to match but a 16-80 is annouced. Don't know how good it will be, but certainly be quite expensive as anything Fuji...
So, for an APS-C shooter, these two lenses makes Pentax a very good option (although we aleready knew that!).