Hi,
It seems like the expensive limited and star series lenses are constantly being recommended (err… praised, worshiped, etc.) on this forum. While I do believe that these are great chunks of glass - I think that the "modern legend" status they have been developing recently is a bit exaggerated. I have owned a couple of star lenses in the past and at one time owned all 3 of the original limiteds (the only one that I kept was the 31mm) - yes they are great lenses, but IMHO they weren't worlds apart from some of the more common, slower Pentax offerings. I find that so many people today are obsessed with "getting the best" (stars and limiteds) that they overlook some truly great bargain lenses. I'm interested in hearing everybody’s picks for the best bargain lenses currently available for pentax.
One stipulation before we start - only list lenses if you have actually used them and have seen the results - No rehashes of 2nd hand web reviews
Ok......here is my list (in no particular order):
1)Pentax 28/3.5M - This has to be one of the best 28mm lenses that Pentax has ever made. It is small, light, and feels better made than any of the auto focus era limiteds or * lenses (well.....this is true of almost any manual era pentax lens). I debated over giving the honors to the 28/3.5 K version of this lens, but in the end the M takes the day. Sure, the K version is commonly thought to be better (I have both - I haven't really noticed any real world difference in picture quality between the two), but the K is relatively hard to find and goes for 2-3x the cost of the M version - just not worth it IMHO.
2)Pentax 50/1.7M - Awesome picture quality at dirt cheap prices. Probably the best bargain currently found in the Pentax world.
3)Pentax 85/2M - This lens gets a really bad rap, but I think it is just misunderstood. Consider this a special purpose lens - IMHO this is one of the best "portrait" lenses that Pentax has ever put out. Yes it is a bit soft wide open, but the images it produces certainly are not mush - and truthfully this softness is what makes it a great portrait lens (who wants to see every zit or wrinkle on the face of the person you are photographing?). When you move past the fast apertures and arrive at the middle apertures it is just as sharp as any other lens. Picture quality aside, its construction is top notch and it is amazingly small for a short telephoto - easy to put in your pocket if you are traveling with a bare bones kit. The street price for this lens may not be cheap but compared to the other Pentax 85mm lenses floating around it is by FAR the most affordable. This is one of those lenses that I will never get rid of (did I mention that it is a GREAT portrait lens ;-P).
4)Pentax 135/3.5M – Easy to find, cheap, good picture quality, probably the smallest 135mm ever made. Yeah, the 135/2.5K may be a hair sharper (and about 3x the cost), but I would much rather carry the M around than the K tank.
4)Pentax 35-105/3.5 A – One of the best manual focus zooms Pentax ever made (maybe the best). Great picture quality, high quality build, a joy to use. Only downside - Heavy!
5) Pentax SMC 70-210/4-5.6 F – Sure it is ugly (looks like it was designed by RoboCop), the autofocus is slow, and the focusing ring is cheesy, but the IQ is FANTASTIC (and it reportedly contains ED glass).
BTW – I shoot film, so I have no idea how these perform on digital – if they suck let us know (actually that would be a great topic for a thread…..”Great Pentax film lenses that are mediocre on digital”)