Originally posted by beholder3 Here is a comparative test: 7 Autofokus-Systeme im Test - PC Magazin
Thanks for the link.
I read a Google-translated version in English, which might have missed some subtle points of language. Please correct me if I've misunderstood the test report.
The test is interesting in that it included a variety of cameras, including mirrorless and DLSR, from several brands. The basic message is understandable: autofocus is less than perfect and users should expect some mis-focused shots, perhaps as many as 25% of shots. Some cameras have worse AF performance than others.
However, there seems to be at least two important technical flaws. It's not obvious that the test procedure included preliminary steps to calibrate the cameras through AF Fine Adjustment or AF Micro-adjustment, for those cameras that have such a capability (Pentax K-1, for example). If this was done in fact, then the article should have mentioned it and briefly described their calibration procedure. If the cameras were not calibrated, the credibility of the test is questionable.
Secondly, the article doesn't seem to distinguish
precision and
accuracy, a common omission in this type of test report.
The report reminds me of a series of technical analyses in 2012 by Roger Cicala at Lensrentals, for example:
https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2012/07/autofocus-reality-part-1-center-poi...shot-accuracy/
- Craig