Originally posted by traveler Sure--that's a fine lens. It was my first (kitted), and had Pentax not worked out so well for me, might have remained permanently mounted as my only Pentax lens. Nevertheless, I tend to think of a 'superzoom' as having more reach--out to 250mm or more.
But despite the notion that superzooms are somehow 'down market,' I see them more as special purpose. Too many compromises perhaps in size and optical qualities to be every day use lenses, but irreplaceable when you really need one.
I bought my Sigma 18-300 for a specific event: the Oberammergau pageant. The requirement: take a lot of pictures at this once-in-a-decade event of everything from wide-angle crowd shots to close-ups of the happenings on stage, while being in an uninterrupted environment of a large, possibly jostling crowd that really doesn't leave much room for safe lens changing or a bag of alternative lenses. Sometimes, only a superzoom will do.
The difference in FOV between 135 and 200-300 is not that big it may sounds like. Especially if focusing on closer than infinity
Superzoom lenses tend to have a much shorter focal length when focused closer than infinity, It is called focus breating, which most lenses suffer from this, but it tend to be much worse on superzoom lenses.
Looking at Pentax three superzoom lenses the difference in focal length at minimum focus distance does not seem to be very large. Pentax tele zoom lenses have much longer minimum focus distance but similar max magnification ratio. Which indicates they suffer less from focus breathing.
DA 18-135 mm / (min focus dist) 40 cm / (max mag ratio) 0.24x
DA 18-250 mm / (min focus dist) 45 cm / (max mag ratio) 0.28x
DA 18-270 mm / (min focus dist) 49 cm / (max mag ratio) 0.26x
DA 50-200 mm / (min focus dist) 110 cm / (max mag ratio) 0.24x
DA 55-300 mm / (min focus dist) 140 cm / (max mag ratio) 0.28x
Sigma 18-200 mm / (min focus dist) 39 cm / (max mag ratio) 0.33x
Sigma 18-250 mm / (min focus dist) 35 cm / (max mag ratio) 0.33x
Sigma 18-300 mm / (min focus dist) 39 cm / (max mag ratio) 0.33x
Sigma 70-300 mm / (min focus dist) 95 cm / (max mag ratio) 0.5x
So the difference in reach of different superzoom lenses may not be as large as the focal length specification indicates.