Originally posted by 247nino Hin, old friend, help me
I am thinking of putting my DA35 out on the market, I think it's focusing speed is a little slow for my taste. Maybe getting the FA31? I also haven't been pixel peeping as much lately, so I've been a little more relaxed on image quality even when printing 12x18s at costco with no problem. Is the FA31 extremely sharp? I have the DA70, which is pretty sharp imo, but how much sharper is this Queen?
I do like that the DA35 is a 1:1 and so small and the build quality is awesome, but for my portrait/modeling work my 16-50 has become my go to lens for anything past 5pm(light).
Since you have had both of these lenses and you have great intuition of what I like, tell me should the DA35 stay with me? Keep in mind I still have the ST35 from you.
I have been out of the States and I don't see your post until today.
Both the 31 and 35 limited should be kept as one's best pentax primes in the Not-For-Sale category. Having both is a luxury that I don't want to be in as it is very difficult decision to trim one over the other. The 31mm limited is a definite choice if you want fast prime in street shooting with superb color rendition and detail. With the 31mm limited, you always get the best detail in the shadow and color stands out as the best prime I have seen. A rich color picture is the norm with this 31mm prime.
Compared to the
Pentax DA 35mm f/2.8 1:1 Macro limited, 31mm lacks the close focus capability. If macro is important to you, stick with the DA 35mm as I find it great for street shooting, portraits in tight space, product shots in a pinch without any elaborate setup, and close up need in all situations. Had it had a maximum aperture in f/2.0 like the FA 35mm f/2.0, it would have been a perfect alternative candidate to the 31mm limited.
As for the 31mm, is it worth the price. It boils down to one's shooting style and need. I find $700 a bit overpriced for my casual style of pictures and I always like fast lens with good close up capability. If I could buy it for the price closer to FA 77mm f/1.8 under $600, I would find it more justifiable. I think I paid $660 + shipping. Will I buy it again even with the presense DA 35mm limited f/2.8, yes
I will as it is still the best and fast lens for that focal length and price. The DA 35mm f/2.8 or the alternatives can't rival the quality and speed of the queen.
As I mentioned before, there are alternative candidates to be considered such as the Pentax FA 35mm f/2.0, Sigma 24mm f/1.8, Sigma 28mm f/1.8, Sigma 30mm f/1.4. In M42 category, there are few and I like the
Czj Flektogon 35mm f/2.4 (m42) with 1:2 close up as a worthy M42 candidate to be considered.