"
Anyone have advice to share regarding a repair? I've only tried a rocket blower, Zeiss cleaner, a PecPad, and a microfiber cloth. I'm thinking some polishing compound might need to happen. It'd remove the coating altogether, I imagine."
I might be a little late on this discussion, but my first advice would be go to ebay and see if you can find a replacement. The thing is these lenses are not cheap. They can run anywhere from $250 to $400+ depending on the condition. Seriously I don't know who would pay that much for an f4.5, 50 year old lens, but apparently this lens is one of the more expensive Takumar lenses on the market for some reason. To keep things in perspective, I paid $150 for my Takumar 8-element 50mm f1.4, and maybe $50 for my Takumar 35mm f3.5 which are both highly rated lenses. From my experience, no amount of polishing is going to remove those scratches from your lens. I once scratched a $110 Variable Neutral Density filter and as hard as I tried, which includes purchasing all types of scratch removal compounds, the scratch is still there and visible although it does not affect picture quality.
In my opinion, your best bet would be to remove the front-element and replace it with another one. However, where are you going to find a front-element replacement for that lens ? You might scour eBay until you find an AS-is model and as long as the front element on that model is not scratched, you can do a 'switcheroo', that's if you have the right equipment. Other than that, a 24mm f3.5 might be reasonable alternative. I have this lens and it performs fairly well, but it's nothing to write home about.
Last edited by hjoseph7; 04-27-2023 at 08:06 AM.