Originally posted by Douglas_of_Sweden claiming that Pentax have never had any lenses as good as the Canon lenses...it would have been fair to hit him in the head with the A*85/1.4
In about year 2002 I waned to buy a fully mechanical pro quality LSR. I am not a pro, so I mostly do not need and hate autofocus and other modern features that claim to make better decisions than I can make myself. In my opinion modern features take fun away from the process of taking pictures. I had to take a decision whether I go with Canon, Nikon, or Pentax, Contax (Carl Zeiss) and Leica were just too expensive and overpriced in my opinion.
At that time I found photodo
Lens search, a website that compared most of the SLR lenses in terms of just physical measurements. This does not take into account several important subjective factors like bokeh, background and "3-dementionality" in prints. They are impossible to be measured directly. I already had some experience with SLRs and I noticed that I often liked sharper pictures.
So I decided to see how many sharp lenses each manufacturer has made. It was easy with photodo. To my surprise I discovered that Pentax lens lineup had not less, but even more outstandingly sharp lenses than the other guys. For my personal consumption I consider photodo MTF of 4.0 as acceptable, 4.2 as excellent and 4.6 as outstanding. Another surprise for me was that German Carl Zeiss and Leica are not any sharper than the Japanese brands. Still another interesting observation was that newer lenses were not any better than the older ones. According to photodo results, some A* and F series Pentax lenses are probably the sharpest Pentax lenses and they are made in 80s and 90s. I did not try the newer limited lenses. I would expect 77 to be around or above 4.0, and 43 and 31 above 4.2 in photodo MTF terms. They are also expensive.
My decision was that in terms of
1) sharpness and
2) price
Pentax beats the other Brands. The added value for me was that the number of K-mount lenses is much more than I can find in any other system thanks to backward compatibility + compatibility with older 42mm. And LX body was such a fun to use!
Still another interesting aspect is who was actually designing and making Pentax lenses. My guess is that they may have had their own designs as well as bought from specialized optics shops. I also think that recently they may have not been making their lenses themselves, but instead outsourcing the production to specialized companies like Hoya (optical glass and optics - Tokina). Same as the others of course.
Any news on whether Hoya actually bought Pentax?
Hoya buys Pentax - Mac Forums
I hate "digital age" in that it hit Carl Zeiss, Leica and Pentax hard. It was all so clear before digital.