Originally posted by myllis Yep, I know that I'am making a compromise. I already have Pentax 16-50mm/f2.8, Pentax 55-300mm/f4-5.9 and Sigma 70mm/f2.9 macro. In some situations (eq. motorsport) you will loose the best picture when your are changing the lens. And two cameras does not sound good idea..
I completely understand your need for a sujperzoom. I had several more specialized lenses when I bought the Pentax 18-250mm. I consider the 18-250 a specialty lens too. Its specialty is "all purpose". It's not the best at anything, but it does everything passably well. That's quite an achievement AFAIC.
I've never tried the Tamron 18-200 but professional and user reviews agree that performance doesn't match the 18-250. OTOH it's a lot cheaper, so it has its allure for some. Looking at the rest of your kit, I think you should move up the line.
The Tamron and Pentax 18-250mm's are identical in construction, but may have different coatings (Pentax advertises smc for its version) and usually carry different warranty periods and price. It was a no-brainer for me because
- the Pentax Canada 2-yr warranty is longer than Tamron's international warranty (1 year)
- the Pentax was cheaper, and
- it says Pentax on it (more prestigious name in case of resale)
The image quality of the 18-250 falls between my 18-55 and 16-45 except at the wide end where it loses ground due to heavy barrel distortion. Pentax rightfully doesn't call a lens like this a macro, but it does have a useful close focus ability. It's perfect for flower heads, useless for insect macros. If you want to add true 1:1 macro, it mates very nicely with a Raynox DCR-150 and you won't notice much if any loss in IQ.
As you noted, the Tamron 18-270 is not offered in Pentax mount (yet?), but early indications are that it doesn't match the 18-250's image quality in Canon mount.
I don't know anything about the Sigma, but I've heard it will be pricier. Tamron up to now has owned the superzoom category, so Sigma will have to come up with a real winner to justify a higher pricetag.
Last edited by audiobomber; 02-04-2009 at 07:12 AM.