Originally posted by Vern This is a very useful compilation Vern. Those reviews are throwing fuel on the LBA fire. And the review from from Photozone, they gave it very good marks across the board, just not the "Highly Recommended" top-mark that we come to expect from Pentax!!
I have an unexplainable desire for this lens. While I've always been a fast prime lens guy, I've never been a macro lens guy. Maybe because they are slow (f/stop) and slow (focus throw).
But coming back to an dSLR from an advanced compact, I really miss having the ability to get in close. (My Ricoh GX-8 could focus on a dime (literally) and fill the frame with it.)
I originally thought I wanted an FA35/2 as a fast all around normal-lens, but this DA35/2.8 is gaining fast.
In the film days, I had no on-camera flash, no SR and fixed speed of film. So, fast f/stop was critical. But now with on-camera flash, SR and on-the-fly ISO adjustment, fast maximum f/stop is less critical to getting a sharp image.
(Aside: I guess that's Pentax's philosophy for the relative slowness of some of the compact DA primes (21mm, 70mm)...go a fraction of a stop slower, then reallocate the cost savings of the smaller glass into the optimizing the quality of the glass and the construction, as well as the gaining the benefits of tiny size. (Meanwhile, Olympus negates their tiny 4/3's bodies by offering enormous and pricey f/2.0 zooms!!!))
(Of course, fast f/stop still allows advantages for shallow-DOF and view-finder brightness.)
So, maybe I can give up the f/2 for the f/2.8 to gain the macro. And the price locally for DA35 is very very good at the moment, compared to USA.
Anyways, back to the original question.
For me, the decision works this way:
A) I don't have any lens at this focal range. B) I do have fast lenses. C) I don't have any lens that can do close up. D) I don't plan to use it on film-body. Therefore, I am leaning towards the DA. Then price is very close and the DA has quick-shift focus, so the decision becomes clear.
(But then again, that bright f/2 viewfinder is sooo tempting....
)
Both lenses seem excellent and cannot go wrong one way or the other, just different strengths and weakness.