Originally posted by wavecurrent I also have the Soligor MC 200mm 2.8 K-mount in a good condition, got my copy really cheap due to a slow aperture. I fixed that myself,
working like new now, the serial starts with 37
I find the lens a little soft wide open and with some PF, gone by F4 and really sharp at F5.6. Here it's mounted on my old favourite film camera, the MX
I also have the MC 300mm 4.5 K-mount, but I haven't really had time to test it yet.
Thanks for the input. I look everywhere and I don't see much mentioning about the Soligor 200mm lens f/2.8 as compared to other versions in f/3.5. Your
K mount also starts with 37 and I wonder if OP post also meant for 37 as the starting digits in the serial number. My 42 looks very much identical to your K mount in cosmetics. I am just guessing the lens may be made by Tokina as in Vivitar manufacturing serial number.
I actually want to solicit opinion in how to test a tele lens, suggestions are welcome. What are easy shooting targets that is not a brick wall? I shoot
similar pictures in f/8.0, f/5.6,f/4.0 and then f/2.8. I mostly found f/2.8 to be too soft and more prone to PF. And I do see PF in wide open apertures, less noticeable when stopped down.
I would not go too crazy looking for this lens unless you find it relatively low cost.
And I find the iris not symmetrical when stopping down. The better lens that is slower that
MAY offer better IQ will be the
Vivitar 200mm f/3.5 by Komine or the
Pentax M 200mm f/4.0 (the K version without M designation will be better one).
Since this lens has fast speed in f/2.8, I originally thought about using it for occasional bird shooting in close range but I find it too short for the purpose. It is my first time mounting
Kiron 2x matched doubler that come equipped with my
Kiron 70-150mm f/3.8 (m42), on my Soligor 200mm f/2.8.
I have 400mm in the shooting from the combo. I am novice in bird shooting and I have a difficult time to catch up with their movement
Soligor 200mm f/2.8 (m42) +
2x matched doubler from
Kiron 70-150mm f/3.8 (m42)
Very soft
CA/PF
Last edited by hinman; 03-12-2009 at 05:50 PM.