Originally posted by Damn Brit Let's dial it back a bit, are you looking for a lens in that range because you need it or because there is a gap in your range?
Have you analysed what focal lengths you use most?
I haven't really made an analysis, but I find the 16-45 little bit short. Basically, I want something similar as I had in the film days - a 28 - 200 mm "tourist" lens but with better quality (that thing was handy but the pictures lacks that final sharpness I want). The short end is sorted out (the 16-45 seems to be a winner by reading this forum) but I need to add that short/mid-range tele part. The 135-400 on the other hand is little too big (physically) to lug around at my city walks and I seldom need that reach during city shooting (that I mostly do).
Anyway - thank you everyone for helping me out.
StevenVH - I actually saw that lens in a shop window yesterday. I may go there and grab it, it looks like a nice piece...