Originally posted by egordon99 I don't recall anyone saying that ANY lens is 180 degrees @ 17mm.... The 10-17mm is 180 degrees at 10mm on an APS-C sized sensor.
Remember, the field of view is determined by both the focal length AND the sensor/film size. What was the answer you got on the other board and what didn't you understand about it?
Lets take a smaller example...forgetting the 10-17 fisheye zoom for the moment since it's APS-C.
A link to a page on the 8mm sigma circ fisheye:
[url=http://www.sigmaphoto.com/lenses/lenses_all_details.asp?id=3319&navigator=4[/url]
Here's a link for the 15mm Sigma Fisheye:
Sigma - Lenses
And here's a link to my 17/4 Fisheye Takumar:
Die Cast Pro - Super-Fish-eye Takumar 17mm f/4.0
All say that FOV is 180* at 8mm, 15mm, and 17mm respectively. My question is how distortion is the variable, and related to the constant FOV at these different focal lengths.