Originally posted by newarts Ease of use may be important to you for ad-hoc macro shots- it is important to me. With the Raynox if you can't get close enough, just clip it on. Admittedly screwing something on is not much more difficult, but takes longer.
I find the Raynox clip on adapter awkward to use - you have to be careful in centering. And it makes the thing take up way more space in the bag than is necessary. At least you don't need to buy anything extra, so that' one point in favor of the clip-on. But the extra $10 it cost me to get the stepping ring to screw it on directly was *definitely* worth it.
Oh, I found a pretty convenient storage case for it - the little zipper pouch that came with one of my Sandisk SD cards.
Quote: I don't know how the Raynox' 37mm diameter might affect vignetting
It's 43mm, not 37mm. At least, that's the filter size. It doesn't vignette that I've seen with any lens I've used, but my lenses are mostly 49mm and 52mm threads, and I've never tried it with anything under 50mm in focal length. It does fine with the DA50-200 at 200mm, but I understand it does vignette with the DA55-300. I imagine it might also vignette with the DA18-250 or any of the larger aperture or larger range zooms like the DA*50-135, DA*16-50, or DA17-70.
Quote: I'm pretty happy with a screw-on Nikon 4T achromat - it is 3.8 diopters IIRC.
I might have gone that way too if it had been easier to find when I was looking, but the Raynox options were the only ones easily available and cheap.
One other option I'm curious about, though - what about the screw-on adapter that comes with the cheap vivitar/phoenix/whatever 100mm macro? I'm guessing it isn't as strong as the Raynox 150, but could be even more convenient.