As I said it on another thread, I would prefer the Tamron 28-75mm f/2.8 for event and wedding over the Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8-4.5. I used both lens for different purposes. I use the Sigma for outdoor where the wide angle serve me well in both landscape and wider shots with my kids. I use the Tamron for event such as wedding and indoor.
The caveats may lie in the missing of 17mm to 28mm, that you have to answer yourself. Assess if group shot is needed for your type of shooting. Or better assess if 28mm is good enough for your shooting.
For formal shooting, I pair up
Tamron 28-75mm f/2.8 with
Pentax DA* 50-135mm f/2.8. Both do well for portraits for me. And a wide angle zoom will make up the lacking as in
Pentax DA 12-24,
Sigma 10-20, and
Pentax DA 16-45. All are good choices of gear.
The Sigma is still a wonderful lens if your focus is on outdoor, good close up with 1:2.3, lighter weight and good focal range. It is a faster lens over the kit's lens and that in DA 17-70. Though it is close, I will find the IQ and sharpness better in the Tamron 28-75mm f/2.8. The tamron is very consistent in performance if you get a good copy. I trust its performance even wide open. And it works well with the flash AF540 with a Spectra Light Diffuser for me also.
You can check my gear for reference where I use the lenses, flash, diffuser/bouncer mentioned above:
- Hin's Camera Gear
- look for Tamron 28-75, Sigma 17-70, AF540 flash and Spectra Light Diffuser
Regards,
Hin