Just my 2 cents
I bought the Sigma a while ago and was disappointed with the IQ at f/2.8 @200mm and returned it. Part of this was because I used to own the older non-DG, non-Macro version of this lens which was (at least my copy) outstanding at all apertures and focal ranges. The other thing I ran into was that it would misfocus when close to the min focusing distance (see dpreview review of this lens).
Anyway there are a lot of happy people with this lens so maybe it was just my copy.. or maybe I was so disappointed when comparing it to my older version that I couldn't see that it was decent on its own.
John