Quote: But FWIW, Yoshihiko Takinami's resolution tests show the FA50/2.8 macro to be the sharpest of all the tested 50's
I concur, at least wide open. I have used the M50 f2, A50 f1,4, F50 f1,7, and FA50 f2,8 macro. At f2,8 the macro trumps anything else I have used, be it a 50 or a Vivitar series 1 70-210. Or anything else.
When closing down the aperture, it's impossible to distinguish the macro from the F50. The macro has a nicer bokeh, but not by much. Colours are pretty good in both cases, hard to pick a winner since I do not use them for the same purposes.
If I had to name the sharpest lens I own, it would be the 50 macro, because of the wide open performance. It's the only lens I feel 100% confortable using fully opened.