Decided to try my hand at a new Sigma 70-200 II to replace the Tamron 70-200 I had that developed a sticky aperture lever.
Many testimonials praising this lens gave me some hope that it would be a winner. In my hands, build quality's great. Good feel and smooth AF action. I had the background knowledge that it was 'somewhat' softer at the long end, and particularly wide open.
Performance? Good, but not excellent.
I bought it for the ability to capture sharp images, esp. in the centre, wide open at all FLs.
The apparent softness at the long end was not expected to be as bad as I found it with this one, and coupled with a halo effect and significant drop in overall contrast wide open I'm now questioning whether others have experienced this same phenomenon... some of my examples:
All images are at 200mm, 100% crops.
Centre, f/2.8:
Slightly off-centre, f/2.8:
Corners, f/2.8:
Now at f/5.6, images were beautifully sharp in the centre, but fell apart towards the corners:
These are but a few I've taken, more to come later...
But before someone criticises my technique in testing this lens, I'll convey that centre shot crops contain the subject aimed for focus, confirmed numerous times by repeated focus lock checks, in calm conditions with stabilised hand-held captures with Tv faster than 1/200. Furthermore, all corner shots were captured using a flat coloured poster/printed paper with sharp details exactly perpendicular to the lens axis, using a tripod when necessary to keep ISO <800. Still not a scientific test, and I'm not trying to make it out as such, however I do know I have not had this sort of issue recurring with the Tamron 70-200 I had, nor even my DA 55-300 wide open.
Another significant issue I had with the lens is its compatibility with the Tamron SP 1.4x TC...
HSM works fine at 70mm, but absolutely will not lock focus at or anywhere around 200mm, and I tested it in
full sun - very high contrast conditions. Hunts back and forth, whether at infinity or close focus, and gives up the ghost after a second - to use it at these FLs with the TC one has to manual focus. The Tamron on the other hand locked on focus swiftly at each attempt, regardless of FL or lighting conditions (OK, perhaps a little slow or not consistent in low light, but in concerts it was simply magic).
Would anyone like to comment on this short and non-representative test on this EX lens that hasn't quite pleased me as I wished it would?
Thank you for reading.
Last edited by Ash; 09-04-2009 at 07:08 AM.
Reason: typo