Originally posted by Pentaxor the question is, are the FA* worth the hype? I believe this is pretty subjective, depending on what is given more value. the Tammy is generally considered as a best performer overall optically, especially in sharpness. colors is debatable since I don't find it pleasing eversince, even in other systems. but as you've mentioned, it has a poor build and troublesome AF. optical brilliance is not just the only thing that is being sought after.
if I may ask, why did some people considered the FA* inferior to the other brands during the film days?
are the FA* much better used in dslr rather than film slr? this is of course if we are going to disregard the FOV and DOF.
The FA*200/2.8 was tested by a famous Japanese magazine CAPA and everything about this lens is fine, except it was beaten by Canon, Nikon and Minolta for wide open sharpness. Being an owner also used it on film, I tend to agree it is not particular sharp wide open. But this is not much of an issue since PP can alter the shots a great deal now. Other popular FA* like 24/2, was never a strong performer. It wasn't sharp until f4, bokeh is bad, flare control is a little weak for a SMC lens, but it was an awesome deal for the price. 85/1.4 was designed for portrait, and does poorly for landscape or macro on extension tubes. 300/4.5 is an odd lens being w/o the lens collar consider most people didn't have sturdy enough tripod/head. Pentax's explanation was that it was designed for handhold, but the lack of SR back then made this rather difficult. As to other FA* like 200/4 macro, 400/5.6, 300/2.8, 600/4 & 250-600/5.6, the 1st 2 came to the market rather late and the rest were expensive and not really what most Pentax users interested in. The truth is, those who could afford that much would probably go Canon or Nikon for better AF. This was not the Pentax domain, and still is not I am afraid.
Just before the digital era, all the Pentax lenses, * or not, did not attract much attention on eBay and there were many reasonable deals. Still, you wouldn't get excited because nobody seemed to be interested in. But since the DS, Pentax users have started to soak them up and the prices inflated quickly, so is the hypes. Anything * automatically became magic and command premium on used market. Whether they worth that much is up to the individuals to decide.