If you don't mind the size, the Sigma 10-20 is a very good choice.
Each lens in your list has it's strengths and weaknesses - you'll have to decide
which to buy depending on what strengths and weaknesses are most important to
you.
Regarding the DA 15 - For me, 'soft' corners at f/4 was pretty much meaningless.
I'll almost never be shooting it wide-open
when I'm concerned about the corners
- when I'm shooting it wide-open, I'm focusing on something in the center, usually
indoors, like the following shots:
.
Stopped down to your typical WA application aperture, f/8 or f/11, it
will have pretty much the same edge sharpness as anything, visible in just about
any print size you're likely to make. Once you realize this, the 'problematic'
corners at f/4 just become theoretical.
As a dedicated wide-angle lens, I don't know if you can beat the DA 12-24 in
overall quality and versatility. What the DA 15 gets you over that is a bit better
flare control, somewhat less CA, and
mostly the ability to throw it in even the
smallest bag to take along anywhere, giving you no excuse to miss a Wide Angle
Shot of Opportunity (WASOO!)
.