Originally posted by vapentaxuser Hello... was wondering if anybody had any reccomendations on a decent upgrade to the kit zoom for the K-5. I noticed the price on the DA* 16-50 lens has dropped to $800 on Amazon but at the same time I have heard some not so good things about that lens.
I have also heard good things about the DA 16-45 lens but that is not weather-sealed (though this is not necessarily a deal breaker).
I have the DA* 16-50 f2.8 and have owned several 18-55 kit lenses.
I almost always have my 16-50 on, but the 16-45 got a lot of work and it is a good lens for the price. In fact, it has been on my K7 getting some work in over the holidays.
I really wanted the 17-70 f4 but it seems to be universally not so sharp, but I may tempt fate and buy one anyway as 45-50mm is often just a bit too short.
I had a non-macro Sigma 18-50 f2.8, which was a steal and performed very well. It was small and well built and quite sharp. Sigma often has many versions of the same or similar lens, but I would definitely suggest looking for the non-macro 18-50 f2.8. I think I sold mine for about what I paid for it, which was $200 or so.
Personally, I just do not buy non-fixed aperture zooms anymore as I do not like thinking about the changing aperture as I zoom, not to mention the impact on flash when the aperture changes. This is why I have never really been too interested in some of the zooms from Sigma or Tamron that others give good reviews about.
This does not mean you should not consider these zooms, however. It depends upon your intended use.
Good luck.
Ray