Originally posted by CMG So then 1/2 stops are 100% accurate but 1/3 stops are a bit of an approximation.....like 50% vs 33.33333%?
Well like I said, it's probably splitting hairs, but yes except it's 0.300 vs 0.333. When I'm shooting on location I have to decide how I want to round off f/8 & 3/10ths, and actually I'd have to do less truncating if I were to use thirds of a stop. But somewhere between f/8 and f/11 one tenth of a stop gets lost, and that bugs me.
In the studio, I don't round at all. My monolights are adjustable in tenths of a stop. Or if I'm using a pack & head system, I'll change the position of the light until I have straight-up-and-down f/8. No guesswork in post for me.
[edit: Because once you get into guessing in post production, you have to ask "Is my monitor calibrated? Has it warmed up for 30 minutes prior to editing? Is my colorimiter working? Is that late afternoon light coming through the window affecting my perception? Do I trust my subjective memory of the scene?" I prefer to never guess.]