Originally posted by crossover37 Thanks all.
I wonder how the K5 would compare to these 5D images. The full frame looks to have a lot of advantages besides shallower DOF.
The Full-Frame Advantage The same issue that applies to film format applies to digital. If you view both images at the same size (final output) you have to enlarge the APS-C image 50% more and it will degrade the image.
The reverse of that is if I take my 5D with a 135L and take a shot and then put my 135L on a 7D take the shot. Now I crop my 5D shot to equal the FoV (200mm) of the 7D image the 5D image stats to fall apart compared to the 7D. The 7D looks better than a 5D image cropped to equal FoV.
MTF charts are tied to sensor height so MTF charts will always favor larger sensors even if there is not visible difference. MTF comparisons only work for equal sized sensors.
Higher pixel density improves image resolution which is why Canon is racing down that path. The 18MP 7D should be able to match the 12MP 5D at lower ISO when it comes to image quality.
Go look at the reviews at DPR or SLRgear for the Olympus 50mm f/2 macro and the Olympus 150mm f/2. These lenses produce images that are stunningly sharp on a 4/3 sized sensor.
Ken Rockwell is probably not the best source for any type of technical information or photographic inspiration. He is really good and making random predictions and generating web traffic to his site.
As far as "the look" goes..... FF cameras have long had a big advantage in DR which has lead to the images looking richer and having more detail. DR does not just impact the shadows and highlights. DR & effective bit depth impacts to tones of the entire image.
"the look" is more lens dependent than anything. The reason the 85L is such a popular lens for creating "the look" is that it is really sharp even at f/1.4 and by f/2 it produces very clear/sharp images with a background that has melted away. Pentax has made lenses like this in the past (A* lenses), but how much of a market does Pentax have for $2,000.00 lenses these days. It will take a couple of year and a couple of more bodies like the K-5 to build a user base that needs that quality of glass...... and an improved SDM.