Originally posted by RGold I'm a new K-5 owner and I'm disappointed with the AF performance when using Tamron 17-50 @ F2.8, using center focus point zoomed out to 18mm. Most times I get image out of focus if I zoom out. Stepping down to F5.6 resolve the issue. For some reason, sometimes, the camera "doesn't bother" the refocus after zooming out if the aperture is below F4.
My test:
1. Focus on an object @ 50mm F2.8. - I can hear the AF motor focusing.
2. Zoom out to 18mm, keep F2.8, point center focus on same object - The focus indicator will lit but no focus correction - the result, image is in bad focus.
3. Focus on an object @ 50mm F5.6. - I can hear the AF motor focusing.
4. Zoom out to 18mm, keep F5.6 point center focus on same object - I can hear the AF motor focusing, image is in good focus!
Is this a lens flow or camera flew?
There are many reports of focusing problems with the Tamron 17-50 on many different brands including some reports on this forum.
I do not exactly understand your test above, but most zooms are vari-focal and they will not hold focus if you focus at one zoom level and then zoom to another without re-focusing.
If the lens obtains sharp results at various zoom settings after re-focusing each time after you zoom, then there is nothing wrong.
If your camera gets sharp results with another lens, your camera is likely ok.
The last possibility is that the Tamron and your K5 are not well calibrated together, but Tamron is not going to calibrate your K5 and Pentax is not going to calibrate your Tamron.
My bet is that, like many others have reported, the Tamron is at fault, but you would need to do more testing to be sure.
Ray