Originally posted by dcshooter Doesn't sound like it. I'd report the seller to eBay.
That is the only issue I see with this.. and a very big potential issue at that. All of the items being sold are initially being sold as 'parts/not working' with all known issues listed (which is OK), but then I suspect some of these are/will be resold as used. Actually, I'm quite sure a lens was already sold here on PF marketplace recently as used but really was one of these parts/notworking items with a story made up. So buyer beware on used items now that the market is flooded with them from these auctions.
On the other hand, I've bought a DA* 16-50 f/2.8, AF540fgz, and a K-r body and all of them work very well. The flash has an issue with the locking ring (it just spins; was listed in the auction details) but the pin works and there is never a real chance of it falling off the camera. There were so many nice lenses initially... tons of FA31 DA55 50-135 etc etc. Most of the FA31's went for around 500 a piece. A few, iirc, had issues with 'grinding' noise when turning the focus ring while others had 'poor focus at low aperture' such I suspect is simple backfocusing. Just fyi.
The real ones to watch are the 50-135 and 16-50 lenses though as there were a shed load of them up with various issues (mostly AF not working which is fine -- switch it to screwdrive or do the sdm trick) but others had larger listed issues. Especially the 50-135 which quite a number had 'loose elements' as the listed issue. Some had completely detached elements visible in the ebay photos.
If the item you are buying has no box and especially no serial number, be wary if you are buying at normal used prices and the item is being listed as used or 'good' condition without any mention of the auctions.