Originally posted by Jonas B It's not a flattering picture, and it doesn't exactly follow the rules.
Hmmm ...
I've circled around this thread for about a month now and keep returning to this - too small!! - pic of Elisabeth.
It's not a flattering picture? Maybe. But a great picture as far as I can tell. There is a certain thoughtfulness and uneasiness I sense looking at it. But I can't nail it, so I keep returning for another look ...
Looking at it I - as one who is very fast in noticing photographic issues - don't think about the photograph but immediately about the person I see - a great achievment IMO.
But one thing, Jonas, forcing myself to think about the photographic aspects: Not following the rules? Come on! You do follow them - and you do it brilliantly.
Wonderful sidelight and perfect choice of in focus area, producing depth and detail where it belongs, a nice diagonal (the cigarette) leading from the left into the image; the eye then is blocked by the dark right side from leaving the pic, travels upward to the right eye perfectly in focus, then looks to the left in the lighter regions, only to be guided again by the cigarette to the right beginning another circle of inspection. Perfect example of how to compose a portrait ...
Phil