Originally posted by gaweidert Since they did not look like the bats used today, I think so. Several players did slap at the ball. but when a fat one come across they would take a swing at it. Also. balls and strikes were not called by the umpire unless the hurler (pitcher) could not get the ball across the plate or the batter would not swing at what the ump considered good enough pitches. Three balls constitute a walk and all players on base advance one base. For instance if a person was on third and first and second were open, a walk would advance the person on third home scoring the run.
As this was the "dead ball" era, swinging for the fence did not necessarily get you a home run. If you hit a foul fly ball and it is caught on the fly or after only once bounce it is an out. With only one umpire, close calls on the bases were settled by the honor system.
The tournament was a lot of fun to watch with as many as three games going on at any one time. We only went one day. I do not know which team won.
The foul bound catch wasn't eliminated until 1883.
In 1879 the number of "called balls" became 9 and all pitches were either strikes, balls, or fouls. Base on balls was reduced to 8 "called balls" in 1880. Also in 1880 a catcher had to catch the pitch on the fly to record an out on the third strike. Base on balls was reduced to 6 "called balls" in 1884, 5 in 1887 (4 "called strikes" that year only) and calls for high or low pitch was abolished, and the current 4 in 1889.
Baseball wasn't really fully modern until the turn of the century...They added a cork to the ball in 1910, and the current live ball appeared in 1920.
Baseball Rule Change Timeline
The first real home run hitter was Dan Brouthers. He hit 107 in his career. He also had 205 triples and a .519 slugging average. Only a few 19th century players had more (Roger Connor, Sam Thompson, Harry Stovey, Jimmy Ryan)
Dan Brouthers - Wikipedia