Originally posted by SSGGeezer Well,is it good, bad, somewhere in between or phony artistic junk? In other words, do you like the effect or would you have gone with the 20mm end of my 20-40 and backed up a bit?
I hate to answer questions like this; it truly is an "artistic choice". Using fisheye changes how the photo looks because it changes angles, sometimes giving a "cool" effect. Backing up changes perspective, which affects angles in a more predictable fashion. At heart, I'm a realist - I like photos that look like the actual thing, so normally my personal choice is to backup - but yesterday on our trip home from Dearborn, I took a photo in Jackson MI in which I chose to use my Sigma 10-20 @ 15mm, instead of my DA 18-135, because I didn't want the {main} street to come between me and the building, even though I knew that choice would cause the near vertical lines of the building to lean more ... I suppose I should have tried both options, because I'm still second-guessing that decision.