Originally posted by UncleVanya You lost me, but I’m interested in your feedback. These are almost the same shot; framing and other factors are quite similar. I do have other shots on the feed - those are framed differently, is that what you mean? As for the minor exposure differences that’s something I can tinker with, these were quick hack jobs as far as processing goes.
I guess I didn't say it very well, did I.
What I meant to say was that this moon was presented to us, from the heavens, as a fascinatingly artfully delivered orb of the heavens. (I don't handle poetic talk very well, I'm afraid!)
But anyway, your bottom shot, with the Tamron lens, actually did that moon shot in a much more pleasing way, considering the subject matter.
I really liked the softer glow of the second shot--making the moon appear more like a gift.
So, I'm not speaking from a technical photographer's perspective on this shot; I'm responding to the feeling I got from looking at the image as a great piece of art.
That lens and your use of it with that exposure, did its work--at least for me!
Angky.