When black and white is done well, especially wth people, to my eye, it is always looks better, IMO. Two points: in the bw version the gray cloud fomation in the (blue)sky beside the snow covered tree (centre) is disturbing. Not saying anything wrong, but it looks disturbing and unreal. 2) notice the foreground shadows in the color version, beautifully defined giving the snow lots of definition and texture. Not that the bw is bad, but it has less texture and shadow. My vote goes to the color version, but they are both nice renditions because it is a great shot.
JMR
Last edited by JMR; 01-07-2009 at 01:03 PM.