Got my HD DA 20-40 today. I put it through it's paces today with the K-1 and KP. First impressions are excellent. I didn't do any focusing via PDAF (where I think most of the confusion over focus and sharpness stems from) but instead CDAF via LV.
On the K-1.
- My feelings are it is usable in 1:1 throughout 20-40 at an f number, it's quite fun and challenging to shoot like this
- 30mm offers the best FF use with least vignetting. Can go down to about 25-27mm and have some mild vignetting still, but a small crop will fix it, basically 30mp shots etc should be feasible at this focal length.
- 23mm is the last focal length you get with staying at f2.8. Heavier vignetting is still there, but again a crop and correction should still see you work with something.
- Hood on or off doesn't seem to make a huge difference to vignette.
Summary on K-1 performance. Quite usable I think from 25-35mm when vignetting is not important, such as portrait work or landscape where some vignette is welcome. I would not use this at all in urban settings or landscape where sky is a large feature and you don't want vignetting at all, even at 30mm I think you will have some issues. To keep vignetting under control I would think of this as a 30/3.5 WR prime and just stick to that focal length (or +/-2mm).
What does give me hope is the fact that adding or subtracting the hood doesn't seem to make much difference to the hardness of the vignette (unlike the HD DA 35.2.8 Macro which has quite strong changes from the hood being extended or retracted). I am so impressed with the contrast and saturation/colours that I am questioning the necessity of a CPL. I think I could get away with just ND filters for landscape use (waterfall shots and the like, which is what I am mostly interested in).
So you get a fully working 30-60mm (FF equivalent) on KP and around 25mm on FF. If using 40mm on K-1 I would just take it off and put it on the KP and use 27mm (where you also get f3.5 instead of f4).
IQ, contrast, colouring are excellent. I shall contribute to this thread in due course with samples.