Originally posted by riseform I checked with a master birder friend. It is indeed a lesser goldfinch
I have pretty good confidence in this mans ID but now I am more confused so I have another person working up at Texas A&M and run it by him also, I truly appreciate the input and love to learn new things especially if it invokves nature
Hello, Robert-good to hear from you! I am sorry to hear that you are having health issues. As the Good Book says, we are all "vessels made of clay". I hope that you will soon be feeling much better and that you will be back out in the field taking your great photographs! I believe that the bird in your photograph is a female summer tanager. Because we are looking at it head on, it is difficult to judge the length and shape of the bill, but it is consistent with that of a summer tanager. In some of my pictures of a female summer tanager, white outer tail feathers are visible. The inner tail feathers are dark. The underside of the female tanager is yellow, with a reddish tinge in "red morph" individuals. Juvenile male summer tanagers, although not uniformly red, have more red on their head and breast than females.
It's great to trade information. Nature photography is a good hobby. Identification of birds can be very challenging. Like people, individuals of the same species can differ in appearance. Although I don't claim to be an expert and I can and do make mistakes, I am going with the id of female summer tanager. Except for vagrants, the location where you photographed this bird is out the summer range for scarlet tanager (they pass through during migration). Hepatic tanagers are farther west, and the field marks and coloration aren't right for female hepatic tanager. My opinion remains female summer tanager. Thanks for the challenge!