Originally posted by Marc Langille Correct: they cannot see the forest through the trees. Those folks have horse blinders on: they only seek the end, nothing else. [EDIT . . . Balance deleted for brevity]
This turned out to be a long reply that most people won't read. That's OK -
As my "other" hobby I fly fish for trout. Fly fishing is equipment-intensive, arcane, requires skill borne of many years of learning and is challenging to do well, but easy to do poorly. It is a broad, multi-faceted hobby that can include tying one's own flies, building one's own rods and collecting historically significant equipment, whether for use, beauty or possessiveness. I tend to shun the latest, carbon-graphite-nano-technology CNC-machined gear and favor the classic, hand-made stuff from the 19th C. through the late 60's. When I have it I use it, but I like to just look at it sometimes and enjoy the work that went into making it. I think that somehow bonds me to and honors the maker, and I treasure that (imagined) personal relationship. Sound familiar?
Missouri and northern Arkansas have a surprisingly large number of streams suited to support fit and naturally-breeding brown and rainbow trout populations. The Missouri Conservation Department manages this resource for sustainability particularly well. Sophisticated fishers have adopted a catch-and-release mentality and have learned to play and capture fish in such a way as to harm them as little as possible.
Most of us "harvest" no more than two fish a year, or enough to provide one fresh-fish meal a season.
A fly fisher is said to progress through four stages of maturity.
A desire to catch:
- Any fish
- Many fish
- Large fish
- Challenging fish
I would add a fifth stage of maturity drawn on length of years fishing:
By that I mean that one has come into harmony with the river one is standing in. One is content to see fish sipping midges from the surface film; watch a Caddis hatch and the resultant feeding frenzy rather than frantically searching a fly box to tie on the closest-matching fly; observe a 24" brown lazily finning behind a log as it waits for prey large enough to be worth expending the energy to pursue (and, knowing I have the skill and equipment necessary to have a good chance to catch it, passing up the opportunity); sit and observe from 4:00am until full-sun the changes in the forest, the river and the activity of the inhabitants (including the benighted people who paddle through).
I have come to the point at which a day where I catch no fish, but make a perfect cast over a hole that SHOULD have a fish in it is a good day.
Perhaps because of my fishing experience I don't have the need to fire off 100,000 clicks to get myself to the challenging shot skill level ASAP. But because of my experiences fishing I understand the self-focused nature of many shooters.
Best thing someone could do for one of those is similar to what my fishing mentor (my brother-in-law) did for me. Patiently show them HOW to get the most out of the experience. Explain that you can accumulate life-long skills by taking the time to learn continually. Demonstrate how to do things the right way. Guide them in their juvenile first attempts and help them evaluate their progress. Enable them to pursue the hobby on their own when they have built the practical and emotional foundation necessary to succeed.