Originally posted by Jeff I agree - I've always liked the bokeh on the 43 and wouldn't change it for the new HD version with more rounded aperture blades. Great photograph - really like it!
What I've found regarding the bokeh of the FA43 (straight blade version) is that while it CAN be a bit busy sometimes (which I personally don't really appreciate), nevertheless a lot of the time, the bokeh ISN'T busy. I guess it depends on the interplay between factors such as the type of background, distance of background, the aperture chosen, the shooting angle, lighting etc.
And I really love that bokeh! It's something special, and beautiful! It's got a character to it, something like a fine grit or texture to it, which I really appreciate and value.
I don't know what causes it to be so, but I've long suspected that the straight blades may have something to do with it.
And if that's true, and if the new rounded blades take away this texture/character from the bokeh, yielding instead bokeh that's merely "smooth", personally speaking I don't think I'd like that. I prize the present bokeh character of the straight-blade FA43.
---------- Post added 06-02-21 at 04:40 AM ----------
Originally posted by Digitalis My fa77 F/1.8 limited developed a crack in the main AF drive gear*, which caused the entire focus ring to seize up:
Fortunately, the entire assembly is able to be ordered in and I was able to restore the lens and now the focus ring turns smoothly once again.
Pentax KP - SMCP-FA77mm f/1.8 Limited.
* Which are made of what I take to be Brass: which is a bit perplexing as I thought the entire idea of using that metal was to avoid corrosion and cracking.
I too had the unpleasant experience of the focus mechanism jamming, the focus ring unable to turn, with a mild "crunching" feeling. It happened to my 77, and then 43.
The authorised Pentax repair staff told me that in both cases it was the same problem — a cracked gear inside the lens.
I'm not sure if it was exactly the same gear as you showed in your photo, but I suspect it would be.
Fortunately, it was quickly repaired, and relatively inexpensively.