Originally posted by Uponnothing The 31a is one of the few Adaptalls I've not owned. I'd pick now up for the right price but they were always a bit too pricey for my liking. I've owned the Tokina 150-500 f5.6 SD which was good and I've seen a comparison that shows through 31a is sharper, but with more fringing due to the lack of LD glass. I've also been lucky enough to own a Canon FD 500mm f4.5L lens, which with the fluorite element has almost zero CA of any kind.
I'd like the 31A at some point to get me nearer my mission of using all the Adaptall range. I'm not far off!
I envy your usage of the Canon FD 500mm f4.5L. I have the Pentax K 500/4.5 and while it is not unusably sharp wide open, the CA can be pretty heavy.
I've used most of the Adaptall-2 SP lenses, except for the 30A 80-200/2.8 and 63B 180/2.5.
The funny thing about the 31A fringing is that there is quite a bit of it, but it is curiously gentle, in that it often is not hard-edged like I've found on some other older film-era lenses. It also sometimes surprises me with a smoother out-of-focus background rendering than I expect.