Forgot Password
Pentax Camera Forums Home
 

Reply
Show Printable Version Search this Thread
1 Like  
Winner - 52-7-06-Colour-Seasonal Color
Posted By: scomatic, 02-18-2015, 08:08 PM

Happy Chinese New Year too all... (not sure your country got celebrating or not)

Wow... this week is getting more participate~ Well done all!

LMignard - Disqualify as the picture were taken not in frame of challenge. But here is the scoring for you:
Technical criteria
- Exposure Focus/sharpness - 7/10
- Colour and/or tonal rendition - 8/10
- Contrast - 8/10
- Lighting - 9/10

Visual and aesthetic criteria
- Framing and choice of viewpoint - 7/10
- Background - 9/10
- Design elements and principles - 6/10
- Visual impact - 7/10

Content
- Emotion / Mood /Feeling -6/10
- Relevance - 9/10

Viewer’s response
- Excitement - 7/10
- Interest - 7/10

Comment: I like the sunlight, but I'm thinking of your framing and choice of viewpoint is a bit lack interesting... maybe different angle might work it better.



mtux - Autumn of mango tree?
Technical criteria
- Exposure Focus/sharpness - 9/10
- Colour and/or tonal rendition - 9/10
- Contrast - 8/10
- Lighting - 9/10

Visual and aesthetic criteria
- Framing and choice of viewpoint - 7/10
- Background - 9/10
- Design elements and principles - 8/10
- Visual impact - 7/10

Content
- Emotion / Mood /Feeling -8/10
- Relevance - 9/10

Viewer’s response
- Excitement - 8/10
- Interest - 7/10

Comment: Your lens play an very important role here... Nice lens! It created autumn feel, and nice bokeh.. But there is room to improve on framing and choice of viewpoint.



ramseybuckeye - is that Ice's river or Sea?
Technical criteria
- Exposure Focus/sharpness - 9/10
- Colour and/or tonal rendition - 9/10
- Contrast - 8/10
- Lighting - 9/10

Visual and aesthetic criteria
- Framing and choice of viewpoint - 8/10
- Background - 7/10
- Design elements and principles - 8/10
- Visual impact - 7/10

Content
- Emotion / Mood /Feeling - 7/10
- Relevance - 8/10

Viewer’s response
- Excitement - 7/10
- Interest - 7/10

Comment: I love the sky feel~ It showed Autumn feel in Winter season. I'm thinking if you can more focus on sky and ice's river... It might give u better point. Because the overall background seem bit bored.



TAMIA - Winter season in forest?
Technical criteria
- Exposure Focus/sharpness - 7/10
- Colour and/or tonal rendition - 8/10
- Contrast - 8/10
- Lighting - 8/10

Visual and aesthetic criteria
- Framing and choice of viewpoint - 8/10
- Background - 7/10
- Design elements and principles - 8/10
- Visual impact - 7/10

Content
- Emotion / Mood /Feeling - 7/10
- Relevance - 9/10

Viewer’s response
- Excitement - 8/10
- Interest - 8/10

Comment: Your photo is OK.. But i thinking will the smaller aperture with slower shuttle speed... Your photo might get less blur...



Helena - Tree in the sky?
Technical criteria
- Exposure Focus/sharpness - 8/10
- Colour and/or tonal rendition - 9/10
- Contrast - 9/10
- Lighting - 9/10

Visual and aesthetic criteria
- Framing and choice of viewpoint - 9/10
- Background - 9/10
- Design elements and principles - 8/10
- Visual impact - 8/10

Content
- Emotion / Mood /Feeling - 9/10
- Relevance - 9/10

Viewer’s response
- Excitement - 9/10
- Interest - 9/10

Comment: The sky and the tree are well combination... Nice picture! I love it~



Dieterson: What flower is that?
Technical criteria
- Exposure Focus/sharpness - 9/10
- Colour and/or tonal rendition - 9/10
- Contrast - 9/10
- Lighting - 9/10

Visual and aesthetic criteria
- Framing and choice of viewpoint - 9/10
- Background - 9/10
- Design elements and principles - 8/10
- Visual impact - 8/10

Content
- Emotion / Mood /Feeling - 9/10
- Relevance - 8/10

Viewer’s response
- Excitement - 9/10
- Interest - 9/10

Comment: I like every aspect of this picture...



jcdoss - After winter effect?
Technical criteria
- Exposure Focus/sharpness - 8/10
- Colour and/or tonal rendition - 8/10
- Contrast - 8/10
- Lighting - 9/10

Visual and aesthetic criteria
- Framing and choice of viewpoint - 8/10
- Background - 8/10
- Design elements and principles - 8/10
- Visual impact - 8/10

Content
- Emotion / Mood /Feeling - 9/10
- Relevance - 8/10

Viewer’s response
- Excitement - 8/10
- Interest - 8/10

Comment: I know the limitation of getting good picture under that kind of weather,, Anyway.. good shot~!



patrick9 - New life after winter?
Technical criteria
- Exposure Focus/sharpness - 9/10
- Colour and/or tonal rendition - 9/10
- Contrast - 9/10
- Lighting - 9/10

Visual and aesthetic criteria
- Framing and choice of viewpoint - 9/10
- Background - 9/10
- Design elements and principles - 9/10
- Visual impact - 8/10

Content
- Emotion / Mood /Feeling - 9/10
- Relevance - 9/10

Viewer’s response
- Excitement - 9/10
- Interest - 9/10

Comment: Amazing photo of glass... Well done~!


RollsUp - A freezed bird?
Technical criteria
- Exposure Focus/sharpness - 9/10
- Colour and/or tonal rendition - 7/10
- Contrast - 8/10
- Lighting - 9/10

Visual and aesthetic criteria
- Framing and choice of viewpoint - 7/10
- Background - 7/10
- Design elements and principles - 7/10
- Visual impact - 8/10

Content
- Emotion / Mood /Feeling - 7/10
- Relevance - 8/10

Viewer’s response
- Excitement - 7/10
- Interest - 8/10

Comment: Nothing special... But i think if the focus point and with more zoom in, the photo will better.



noelcmn - That flower catching fire?!
Technical criteria
- Exposure Focus/sharpness - 8/10
- Colour and/or tonal rendition - 9/10
- Contrast - 9/10
- Lighting - 9/10

Visual and aesthetic criteria
- Framing and choice of viewpoint - 9/10
- Background - 8/10
- Design elements and principles - 9/10
- Visual impact - 9/10

Content
- Emotion / Mood /Feeling - 9/10
- Relevance - 9/10

Viewer’s response
- Excitement - 9/10
- Interest - 9/10

Comment: A bit out of focus feel... Ermm, should be the lens issue?



Bill2849 - New life after winter?
Technical criteria
- Exposure Focus/sharpness - 8/10
- Colour and/or tonal rendition - 8/10
- Contrast - 9/10
- Lighting - 9/10

Visual and aesthetic criteria
- Framing and choice of viewpoint - 8/10
- Background - 8/10
- Design elements and principles - 7/10
- Visual impact - 7/10

Content
- Emotion / Mood /Feeling - 7/10
- Relevance - 8/10

Viewer’s response
- Excitement - 8/10
- Interest - 8/10

Comment: I think if you can zoom down the picture... the picture might create it better feel...



Arn - Few boat is enjoying the astonishing sunset...
Technical criteria
- Exposure Focus/sharpness - 8/10
- Colour and/or tonal rendition - 9/10
- Contrast - 9/10
- Lighting - 9/10

Visual and aesthetic criteria
- Framing and choice of viewpoint - 9/10
- Background - 8/10
- Design elements and principles - 8/10
- Visual impact - 8/10

Content
- Emotion / Mood /Feeling - 9/10
- Relevance - 9/10

Viewer’s response
- Excitement - 9/10
- Interest - 9/10

Comment: How you catch this kind of sunset? It's superb... love it!


The ranking of this week challenge:

Honor Mention: Arn

3rd place: Dieterson & Noelcmn




2nd place: Helena


1st place: patrick9


Any comment is please to state out... I worry my mood was make me mistake in judging...
This is very hard for me to judge the photo of the week... it seem so many good photo are around...


Oh ya... ramseybuckeye & Jcdoss please rate or review my photo please!

Last edited by scomatic; 02-18-2015 at 08:15 PM.
Views: 2,299
02-20-2015, 01:27 AM   #16
Senior Member




Join Date: Jun 2014
Posts: 211
Thanks scomatic for the judging, especially for the nice feedback to my picture. I am glad you liked it!

And of course congratulations to Patrick9, Helena, Noelcmn and Arn :-)

02-21-2015, 04:37 PM   #17
Site Supporter
Site Supporter
ramseybuckeye's Avatar

Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Hampstead, NC
Photos: Gallery
Posts: 14,097
Congratulations Patrick, also Helena, Dieterson, Noelcmn and Arn. Patrick, I hope this weeks weather didn't kill that. My son lives up in Clarksville and they were hammered. Thanks for the great challenge scomatic. The water is neither river nor sea, but a man made reservoir which sits up above the ground. I was in the car with my wife when it started to look like a good sunset, however there was nothing of interest, I decided to head for that reservoir and hopefully get reflection of that ice. I didn't make it in time, the sun was already below the horizon, hence with the upground reservoir there is no background really, so I went with that boat ramp as a foreground. And that was the best colr we had that week! LOL.
02-21-2015, 06:38 PM   #18
Site Supporter
Site Supporter
patrick9's Avatar

Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Murfreesboro Tennessee
Photos: Gallery | Albums
Posts: 3,457
It survived better than our house. Clarksville isn't that far from us .
02-22-2015, 01:56 PM   #19
Site Supporter
Site Supporter
ramseybuckeye's Avatar

Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Hampstead, NC
Photos: Gallery
Posts: 14,097
QuoteOriginally posted by patrick9 Quote
It survived better than our house. Clarksville isn't that far from us .
Very sorry to hear that, hope the damage isn't too bad. I'd guess you're probably just a little over an hour from Clarksville. Whenever we go down there it's a whirlwind visit, I'd like to spend some more time in Nashville, there's sure a lot of hoto opportunities" there. My son is on the higher ground side of Clarksville, probably over 100 feet above the Cumberland.

02-22-2015, 03:46 PM   #20
Site Supporter
Site Supporter
patrick9's Avatar

Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Murfreesboro Tennessee
Photos: Gallery | Albums
Posts: 3,457
It wasn't horrible. Our Florida room started leaking. soaked everything about an inch of water on the floor. I will have to reseal when the weather permits. IF I can locate the leak on the roof area. And probably replace the flooring which we had been talking about doing anyway.
Yeah Clarksville is a little over an hour away from us. I have been there a few times.
Reply

Bookmarks
  • Submit Thread to Facebook Facebook
  • Submit Thread to Twitter Twitter
  • Submit Thread to Digg Digg
Tags - Make this thread easier to find by adding keywords to it!
background, choice, comment, criteria, excitement, impact, mood, principles, response, viewpoint
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Project 52 52-7-06-Colour-Seasonal Color scomatic Weekly Photo Challenges 35 04-02-2015 06:26 PM
Project 52 WINNERS 52-7-05-Colour-Wild Colour Tamia Weekly Photo Challenges 16 02-15-2015 02:13 PM
Project 52 52-7-05-Colour-Wild colour scomatic Weekly Photo Challenges 26 02-13-2015 08:04 AM
Weekly Challenge Winner Project 52 52-7-04-Colour-Black and white patrick9 Weekly Photo Challenges 17 02-07-2015 07:38 PM
Project 52 Project 52 - 4 - 10 Colour - Red - WINNER Graham V Weekly Photo Challenges 13 12-15-2011 06:52 AM



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 08:55 AM. | See also: NikonForums.com, CanonForums.com part of our network of photo forums!
  • Red (Default)
  • Green
  • Gray
  • Dark
  • Dark Yellow
  • Dark Blue
  • Old Red
  • Old Green
  • Old Gray
  • Dial-Up Style
Hello! It's great to see you back on the forum! Have you considered joining the community?
register
Creating a FREE ACCOUNT takes under a minute, removes ads, and lets you post! [Dismiss]
Top