Thanks everyone for participating in this weeks challenge. I really liked the photo’s, even though it’s not a genre I shoot myself for a couple of reasons, one off which is that the city I live in is not very well “suited” for it. The judging was not an easy one. As we all know, art is really subjective and as photo’s are (hopefully) shot with personal preferences in mind, the feeling of the photo’s is really diverse. A lot of the photo’s would work great as a big print and there are even a handfull that could easily be converted to a neon “enhanced” sign for a 50’s diner. Bit of a shame we lost CraigR’s photo during the week. I tend to do my “judging” during the week to make the final report a bit faster, so I already “judged” his when i found out that I was 1 photo short.
Then for the judging itself. My choice was between two photo’s and I have been going back and forth a couple of times. Both are shots that i like a lot, but for entirely different reasons. That makes these challenges challenging I suppose and it’s also the reason I love participating and occasionally, when I got lucky, judging them. The numbers 1 and 2 could just as easily have been the other way around on any other day, but for today this will be my choice (I think).
gump - Hear me roar : in this one I like the skewed symmetry. Also, the clean foreground offset by the “busy” background make this a photo that works well. It has the after hours city feel you see in cities where the center is mostly “unpopulated”. The lion is also pretty good in the spotlight. No idea if that was on purpose or that the lion and the lanterns are part of a bigger structure. I would guess the latter though, but the framing makes you wonder and that adds to the photo.
jacamar - metro ride : I had to check the comments as I would have assumed it was a train. This is a really strong photo created by the polar differences between the two passengers. The man is active and seems a bit excited about where he is going while reading and the lady seems bored and far far away in her thoughts. Even the coice of clothing of these passengers are opposite to each other. Also I noticed this is another GRIII photo. If this continue I will have to blame you guys for getting one, although if I would I would opt for the GRIIIx i think.
aaacb - dry cleaner : this one most certainly qualifies, so no worries in that department I would say. I really like the strong colors of the neon signs against the dimly lit store. The downtown after hours on a rainy day in autumn feelings are really strong in this photo. I saw there was a comment that suggested cropping of the car, which I think is not the correct choise. i would probably have darkened or blacked out the car as the dark space itself works really well.
atupdate - Hot : i liked your “old” photo a lot, the only downside was that it did not fit the parameters, this photoI however is what I was looking for. I like it how this photo sets the atmosphere with almost only one color, being red. The dimmed out background combined with the bright red accents work wonders on the photo.
Hattifnatt- Camden Market : what I really like about this one is the harshness. It looks like the food market is closed at the time of the photo and the person sitting there waiting for “better” times, slightly bored watching the tablet and waiting for customers. But as the gate is closed it might be some time. Even though it is more during the day, this photo brings the proper “dark” feeling.
Photos-by-Chas - Oklahoma storm : a lightning strike is still something that is on my bucket list. I have never been able to get one. Yours looks very good though. I really like the purple hues in this photo as it makes it stand out from what you normally see.
Green&White - Street vendor : really great photo. I like the feeling in this one. Everything is more or less obscured in darkness except for the one street vendor. He himself has a little light, but there is also some other light somewhere as it looks like he is sitting in the spotlight. You still have a lot of detail in de photo, although I can not make out what the man is selling. If I would have to guess I would say chestnuts.
Yaki - Easter : don’t worry, your photo is perfectly fine. Churches and chapels already have “dark vibes” from them selves, at least the old ones. New ones have modern lighting which spoils the mood. What I like in this photo is that it seems like you are a “distant” observer as the photo seems to be taken from the other side of some kind of gate. The reader is fully unaware of this observation. If you go there again, i would love to see this photo without the bigger lightbulbs, it might make it even stronger.
PintofDog - St mary’s Lighthouse : this is a bit of another take on the theme, but it is a very good one. I really like the detailed very dark and gloomy weather background. It looks like a big storm is brewing. The parent and child in the foreground in the darkness trying to reach the safety of the house give a nice contrast against the rainbow lighthouse. The rainbow colors also cheer op the atmosphere in the photo. Great photo taken at the perfect time.
noelcmn - church/chapel : this could almost be a scene out of a thriller. An empty, what I suppose to be, a church and a stranger walking in. But looking more closely I will have to assume it is “just” the pastor walking in. So, the dark vibes are really present in this photo. The symmetry also make it stronger. Your choice of making this photo in a for the rest empty church only adds to it. The only thing I think I would have liked a tiny tiny more would have been stained glass panels, although that is a bit compensated by the blue glass at the bottom of the windows, giving that tiny bit of extra color.
Hcarvalhoalves - Street scene : great choice, of all the ones you posted I liked this one the most. I like that it is an buzzing shop in a for the rest dark environment. The photo in itself is not really “dark” though, it feels more joyful. People enjoying their late night pizza and the socializing. Somehow it has the early summernight feel to it and judging by your exif data i am not really far off. It is a scene you will not really encounter where I live, as life is more geared towards inside, but I love this kind of atmosphere.
Jheu02 - train station : a shot that looks like you took it in the early morning. People hardly awake on their way to wherever they need to go. I like the lines in this photo, especially the rails that have the reflection of the lights in them. The “floating” office building rising out of the mist ads to the feel of the photo. Although I myself do not visit train stations a lot I always like the feel of them. Somehow the connection to far away locations makes them different from other places.
1. Green&White
2. jacamar
3. Hattifmat
4. aaacb
And a honorable mention for everyone else as I really enjoyed all the photo’s and there were so many of them, and i love to see that. Normally I pick 1 or 2 for this, but this time i could not choose.