I paid around $200 for mine. I really don't consider it "quirky". It has performed well for me. The biggest issue is the size and weight and lack of a tripod collar. It has some issues with CA but that's true of most older glass, not just this lens. Here's a shot wide open at f/4. This was a mistake. I was taking some shots of bikes and riders during a break and I had swapped lenses. I put the 300 back on and went back to racing shots, only to realize much later that I had been shooting at f/4. The histogram looked ok and the shots looked OK on the camera's LCD but when I got them up on the computer, there was purple fringe, green fringe and even some orange outlines. It took only a couple of clicks in Lightroom to get rid of it.
Most of the shots were usable but I didn't have quite as many keepers as when I was stopped down.
Here's a cropped shot I took this spring of a kite surfer.