Originally posted by Rondec In general, I have felt like Dp review's reviews are usually pretty balanced, up till the conclusions. It often seems like one author will write the main body of the review and then someone else will summarize it -- often with conclusions that seem at odds with the main body of the review.
I don't particularly put too much stock into previews, since there will be a review that follows that is more thorough and hopefully informative. I am not sure why they delete comments that are not out of line, but that is why I don't go over there much. Seems like this forum is a lot more open, with discussions continuing freely as long as folks stay in-bounds.
Pretty much sums up what I think, even though I wrote a couple critical posts about the dustup. I am more annoyed by what felt like a sloppy error than the pre-conclusion, and I wrote and still believe the corrected preview is fair. I'm always upset that they don't leave comments in place.
Once it was corrected I thought the preview was actually pretty good, essentially, "Potential for great images, but we don't understand the design." That last is the critical element of all reactions to the K-01 - "
We don't undertand the design."
I bought one. I like it on first impression. I understand the
vision (large body, small lenses) but I don't understand the design
implementation yet, I don't think. I've made 485 clicks for maybe 5 real photographs. I'm doing my best to change my thinking and habits to make the design implementation work and I believe I'll get there - then I'll love certain bits and hate other bits and ignore most of the bits and take pictures. I do wonder about the utility of having to change
so much habit to get the implementation to work - but that's Pentax.
I hate the manual. If this is what all new dSLR purchasers go through when they get a new camera then I now know why the vast majority of dSLR users are reported to never shoot anything other than Auto. Tell me how to
use the damned thing, not what every button changes!! I only care what a
combination of buttons and Menu Settings does to the final image - or how to coax what I see onto the card. To get
this, set
that!! Screw the SCN Modes. Tell me the underlying settings and let me do them myself. That's all the fun!! Gone are the days of 24 page, 4x6, saddle-stapled user manuals. Good Grief, 272 pages of 8pt. type.
Why isn't there a Herbert Keppler book for today's cameras?
DPR will do the same thing I'm doing - they'll make a lot of clicks. They'll love certain bits and hate other bits and ignore most of the bits and take pictures of some bottles and clocks and rulers and crayons. They'll write their full Review. I likely won't agree with it. Unfortunately I do not believe they will judge the camera with an open mind.
Everyman and all that. I guess I ain't Joe Everyman.