Originally posted by reeftool I read those stories a few weeks back. The high numbers of smokers in Europe were being mentioned as the cause of the higher death rates. Then the smoking prevents covid-19 stories hit. It was then that I came to the conclusion that the old saying that 99% of everything is BS is still true and especially everything you hear and read about covid-19. My take on all this is that health officials don't know jack s***. Govt. officials know this but won't come out and say so but their actions say it all. Quarantine the whole world and "'maybe" this will go away. The press and media grasp on every bit of information and make headlines out of even off the cuff remarks and or some statistic that is probably meaningless.
Government officials (and the general public, let's be honest here) are not well versed in proper, nuanced data analysis.
There is no necessarily contradictory statement regarding smoking, as there is a
very substantial difference between "Nicotine may inhibit the infection from SARS-CoV-2" and "Smoking prevents COVID-19 deaths".
-Nicotine is
not the only thing in tobacco messing up your lungs.
-Not only that, damage to your lungs and heart from smoking takes more than a decade to recover.
-Smoking rates in Europe (and elsewhere, much to the dismay of Philip Morris et al.) have been plummeting for a while.
-
Complete speculation* based on hastily analyzing the data: This could lead to a seemingly paradoxal situation where
ex-smokers are at much more risk because their lungs are damaged, more easily inflamed and at risk of infection, while
current smokers "enjoy" the preventive effects of nicotine itself. The data could support this as most patients are in an age range that would have -statistically- been composed of smokers either actively or passively** In fact, the research paper quoted starts by saying that smoking itself is a terrible idea but nicotinic patches may be an alternative (if it doesn't lead to smoking down the line at least).
*Disclaimer: I'm currently employed as a researcher and I have been trained as an engineer so I have had both the need and opportunity to sharpen my critical and logical thought - but that has never stopped me from being utterly wrong and/or from saying blindingly stupid things
frequently on occasion
.
**Air quality and passive smoking are also typical predictors for lung diseases and cause lasting damage. Passively smoking would have been massively more common just one or two decades ago, until smoking in public places was restricted - I know I was incapable of going to most clubs before Spain passed a law outright banning smoking in bars/restaurants/etc.