Originally posted by Steve Beswick Don't get me wrong, 2001 is probably the best SciFi movie ever.
Delete the "probably".
I admire Emmerich for his ability to make Hollywood movies like no other German can. However, his problem is his movies are even more Hollywood than Hollywood movies themselves. He consistently overdoes it. Good for the box office, bad for the movies.
"Independence Day" was dripping with patriotism. "Godzilla" had great potential but suffered from too much action and too little mysticism and the usual Hollywood Holes of Logic in the plot.
My favourite of him is still "Stargate" despite the unfortunate occupation with the army.
I'll have to see 2012 for the special effects but I already know I'll have to suffer through some tacky Hollywood characters and plot.