Originally posted by Leaf Fan As far as retesting, I am a firm believer in retesting of ALL drivers on a set timescale, something along the lines of every 5 years for people under 60, 2-3 years for people 60-70, and every year above that.
Unfortunately, retesting as a concept doesn't stand up to critical examination.
Think about who causes the most accidents? That demographic is held by the newest drivers, the teen aged to mid 20s drivers, or more to the point, the ones who are most recently tested.
It's not that they don't know how to drive, it's that they willfully ignore the rules of the road and drive without consideration for others.
Anyone can behave themselves for the 15 minutes it takes to pass a skills exam, anyone can brush up on the rules ong enough to pass a test.
This doesn't mean they will apply this to operating a vehicle, and unfortunately the facts bear witness to this.
Retesting will take the people off the road who are plain and simply incapable of proper driving, but honestly, that is an incredibly small % of bad drivers.
The rest of them are bad drivers because they choose to be bad drivers.
They just passed a law in Saskatchewan banning cell phone use while behind the wheel, though it's still OK to use a hands free device.
Yippee!!! Yesterday I saw 6 or 7 people driving while talking on a cell phone, and a couple of people obviously texting, but they were holding the devices on their laps so that someone beside them couldn't see the phone.
The new law so far seems to have little impact other than to force the people who are aware of it to take their attention even farther from the road.
And in the meantime, the fine for getting caught is about the same as doing a U-Turn at an intersection that is controlled by street lights, which is something that isn't inherently dangerous, though someone decided to arbitrarily pass a law banning it.
Rupert is right in that using a cell phone while driving puts you in a state of mind similar to being well over the legal limit for alcohol.
With this in mind, why isn't the law reflecting that fact? We take drunk drivers off the road, take their cars from them and give them hefty fines and/or jail time.
Why not do the same thing with cell phoning while driving?
Why not take a persons cell phone from them after an accident and see what it was doing prior to the collision? If it was in use, why not make it a manslaughter charge rather than a traffic violation?