Originally posted by Nesster Rupert, no where did I suggest you should change your way of thinking, only that there may be nuggets of gold among those other nuggets
... and if you re-read what I wrote 'another' way, might I be talking about Ratlady's "persecution complex" just as well?
Nice stuff, Nesster: bear in mind though that it's a lot less benign than some people think, ...when for starters, people want to bully you around every discussion, claiming to be perfectly righteous, and then expecting one not to point out that the people and ideologies they support keep trying to push manifest injustices one one somewhere every day.
Whenever I say something about how these 'values votes' aren't what they seem, people accuse me of talking about *sex.* But I'm *talking* about people's lives. Lives that are in fact expected to suffer in silence so some corrupt, incompetent conservative pol can get elected or stay in power, ...by stoking anger and confusion that certain favorite targets are always the first to feel, especially in hard times brought about by their own policies which need scapegoats.
It doesn't help with the Democratic party, either: the LGBT vote is *taken for granted* because the Republicans are invariably so much worse to us, and you have a good five to ten percent of the nation voting defensively and hoping someone keeps a promise once in a while.
Then these guys here, while denying it does any harm, say it's indecent for me to report it. Or respond. Cause of who I happen to be.
The dynamics of homophobia and other forms of xenophobia run all through these kinds of political nastiness. Certainly, denying the element of religious-based bigotry and ambition for control in *so* much of what's been going wrong in this society just means that a certain few with varying amounts of bigotry can say crude things and say, "God's on my side. You are unworthy to speak. (Speak bout *anything,* to some, for instance on the basis, "Because you're not like my religion demands, you're 'against all good." Or, "Be a good queer or I'll bash you all." )
Everything *about* the societies we're debating depends on reason, equality, freedom, and the rule of law.
Not that.
Maybe if people want government to *work,* elections should turn on something more than people feeling like they have a right to take a vote on how many human rights people should actually enjoy.
To bigots, it may merely be about 'defending a comfy and self-aggrandizing 'definition' of this or that...' They fearmonger about "What might happen if we don't make sure everything government does harms LGBT people at every possible turn... We're being 'persecuted' if you tell us about the actual effects on real people and our nation's function!"
The fact is that the whole conservative agenda wants government to shirk social responsibilities, ...And to impose their religious will for them on *personal* responsibilities.
Which is, of course, backwards.
It's not just about me or my dearest. It's about everyone.
Yeah, every day I look at the news and see some move by someone to try and oppress or marginalize my civil rights and dignities on the same counts: Not obeying their bigotries. It's not so much a 'persecution complex,' as... Resentment. And very little remaining patience. When the same preachers that want to run the government go to Uganda and get laws passed that call gay people child rapists and thus demand execution for anyone who has gay sex twice, (And Ugandan prison for the first time you're caught... Also for being an accused person's lawyer, not turning them in, or for speaking ill of the law. )
Same people are behind a lot of the Palin candidacy, Michelle Bachman, that whole 'Family' influence group in Washington, trying to get every equality or hate crimes law abolished all over the country by spreading still more hatred and lies... ...look at 'Repent Armadillo,' getting paramilitary all over the place, threatening the UU for 'harboring Pagans,' ...People being run out of their places of business cause someone whispers allegations of 'Satanism,' ...rising statistics of hate crimes, rising numbers of LGBT youth kicked out to the street, where I assure you it's *darn* hard to stay out of sex-work, (maybe so some closeted preacher or Republican politician can go slumming at quite a discount, you know....)
And they say that Christians should feel 'persecuted' if they can't keep the word *marriage* just to themselves. When it's really about a lot more. They say it's about legislating a 'sin,' and deny it *affects* so many aspects of people's lives. And if they can do it to a few groups, they'll do it to more. This is how countries end up turning into some pretty ugly things.
Consider, too, even if you're straight, that if they criminalize *us...* or other religions, well, just like the rest of the Red Scares and witch hunts and people thrown in concentration camps or stoned in the street or beaten to death... Raped and made afraid of more of the same from their own police, (which bad old days aren't entirely behind us... There are people on sex offender registries in this state and others and treated as child predators, simply because they were perfectly ordinary gay people when that was illegal: at Stonewall, they weren't rioting about the *decor,* you know. )
...No one said the accusations even have to be *true.* Could be you, your kids, your neighbors that get it.
On a more daily level, how many of you straight guys can honestly say you were never inhibited against doing something you wanted to do or felt was right because you were afraid it'd be seen as 'too gay?' Too 'wussy' 'femmy' or whatnot? (Come on, if you were photographers in high school, you may well have heard it. Which is funny, cause it wasn't 'feminine' enough for the gals, either.
)
That, I think, goes right down to these hypermacho-insecure ideas of how to run our nation ...even our souls, on *so* many issues.
If others aren't free, neither are you, even if you think the cage fits OK at the moment.
It's been about other people before, and they'll probably try it again with someone else when they can't get any more out of the homophobia, if it doesn't end with us. This time, it's me. That's all.
People try to dismember my rights and life and anything from my perspective into a 'fringe issue,' (...that is, when I'm not being considered as someone it's appropriate for some to take out their frustration and anger and repression and fears on) but to me, this is about freedom and America. My part of the line to hold, when some want to shatter us all into wedges to further divide us.
The targets differ. The irrationality and denial, mean-spirited hatemongering, and the mass deceptions we just can't afford when we as a society need to get together and cooperate the *most,* are the same, though.