Originally posted by Breakfastographer I don't agree with the apparent consensus here that aperture being wide open explains why face AF is not working. That's just kicking the ball into the long grass.
Eric, you should probably
try back button focus. That way, your focus should not slip off the next time you press the shutter button.
I'm not sure if it is relevant but using live view I've found most lenses partially stop down (on my k3), but I'm unclear if they remain so during focusing. It isn't clear if this is due to brightness of the scene or some other factor.
If the lens normally stops down some during focusing, it might be more difficult to focus without aperture control given the very shallow depth of field of that lens wide open.