Originally posted by fs999 But I cannot let say the K-5 has a poor AF. Comparing a 1000 € camera with a 2000 € camera is not fair too.
The € and US$ prices for the K-5 and Canon 7D are not the far from each other. For instance on amazon.de: K-5 = € 1149, 7D = € 1461.
Originally posted by fs999 I used the DA* 50-135mm and the focus was fast and accurate.
I'm glad for you that the lens is fast enough for you, but in absolute terms that lens is known to have slow AF. The K-5's AF is quicker than that.
Originally posted by Rondec I'm convinced that this is more an example of poor Pentax QC. Falk's study evaluated just one camera as I recall.
But he only started the study after many users complained about the K-5's low-light AF.
Even after the study and the new firmware more than just one user complained about AF inconsistency in certain conditions.
It would be nice if one could reduce all K-5 AF problems to bad copies, but I'm afraid it is not that simple.
Originally posted by rparmar Want accurate AF for 99% of applications? Pentax is perfectly fine.
Want adequate photos for 99% of all applications? The cheapest Sony Cybershot is perfectly fine.
Who defines what "99% of all applications" are? If I shell out >$1000 for a camera, I should be excused for having expectations towards its performance. I might also be excused for having applications for it that go beyond the "99% of all applications of all shooters". Why would I need fast lenses and high ISO performance if I didn't want to get good results in restaurant light? And apparently it escaped you that people had/(have?!) problems in studio light? Can they use MF? Of course they can. Should they be forced to with a >$1000 DSLR? Not in my book.
Originally posted by rparmar In any case, get the correct camera for your needs and stop the ridiculous bitching.
Pardon me?
What if people believe the K-5 is the best choice overall but take issue with its AF? What if people want to use Pentax lenses and need a Pentax camera to do so? Are you telling all of them they should switch brands? You cannot be serious.