My take is SDM has a perception issue. There are incidents of SDM failure on the web, sometime the same incident being repeated many times over and over and over. It may be a small percentage it may not be. It doesn't help that there's no statistics on failures as an industry like the automobile industry. The PentaxForum SDM failure survey that Adam ran, doesn't show a decrease in failures over time. I believe a lens rental company said the failure rate was the same for all manufacturers and that SDM didn't have a higher rate of failure vs Canon/Nikon ring motors.
However, when it's your lens that fails, all the industry statistics or hearsay doesn't help. The warranty period is 1 year in the US, I believe Canada is different. I would like Pentax to at least address the issue. If they truely believe theirs no issues with the SDM motor, then extend the warranty on the SDM motor only. Simular to new automobiles, 3 years bumper to bumper, but powertrain is 7 years. Extend the SDM motor warranty to 3 years.
I personally haven't bought an SDM lens because of this perception. I've shot with the the DA* and would love to own them, but if the motor is going to fail on me during a shoot, then I don't need the headache.
Perception is reality. Reality is not perception.
Last edited by 7samurai; 11-02-2012 at 01:20 PM.
Reason: typo