Originally posted by builttospill Reading a statement like this makes me wonder if you've even owned the DA 17-70. It's not an old lens, and it's optics are incredible. There are other lenses being discussed in this thread which may be in dire need of an upgrade, such as the discontinued DA 16-45 or FA 20-35.
If you mean SDM itself is in dire need of an upgrade, then I'll agree with you. But then 17-70 is just one of many SDM lenses, and it's one of the newer SDM lenses at that.
You're correct, and my reason for staying away from the DA 17-70 f/4 comes from a couple comments (copied from PF lens review of this lens):
"The Pentax lens is a different matter. Sadly, we must report that hunting occurred frequently with our test sample. Good lighting conditions were not a problem, but as soon as light levels started to fall, hunting problems began occurring. Problematic conditions included contrasty subjects in well-lit rooms, focus charts, and low-contrast subjects under sunlight. Hunting occurred more often when the center focus point was selected. When using the focus test chart, closing the selected aperture surprisingly increased the occurrence of hunting. This last observation leads us to believe that the issue is electronic and not optical."
And this:
"Because of the Pentax lens’s hunting problems, we feel the Sigma lenses are a better choice."
Now, of course this could be sample variation and PF just got a bad copy. It also comes down somewhat to price. The Sigma EX 17-50 f/2.8 is down to 399€ after the recent price drops while the DA 17-70 f/4 is 576€ (about the same price as the Sigma was originally). The price gap is negotiable, and I wouldn't hesitate to go for the Pentax if it's as good optically as the Sigma EX and doesn't have focusing issues on a K-5.
Although the Sigma gets a point for the extra stop of speed, the DA gets a point for longer reach, so in my book they balance out, assuming the optical and AF performance are similar. Anyone who has owned both lenses care to comment, assuming price is not a deciding factor? Which lens would you go for?