Back in the day if you were carrying a 1.5 lb prime you handling some very unique glass (even the 85* 1.4 is a nearly a quarter pound lighter). In 1980, at about 1.5 lbs I had 2 primes (50,28) and a consumer tele zoom (80-200) and that was my entire kit.
Originally posted by Corto-PA Way too big for what?
For hand carrying all day. I don't use a strap.
For the focal length
For nice balance on my Pentax DLSR without a grip
Earlier in the thread someone suggested these beautifully sharp, and heavy lenses are for the viewer and not the shooter. I guess if I was getting paid for my images that would make sense. Because it would be work lugging these lenses around. But photography for me is mostly for my enjoyment.
Of course everyone has their own needs and where their tradeoff points are.