Staff note: This post may contain affiliate links, which means Pentax Forums may earn a small commission if a visitor clicks through and makes a purchase. If you would like to support the forum directly, you may also make a donation here.
I love the term thoses reviewers use. "Usefullness"... some other use "decency level" or "barely usable" for a lens that is not at top lp/lw on extreme corner at f/1.4...
So let see the weak look of FA31 at f/1.8 even in web resolution at around 1000px (from flickr):
And let see what photozone say out of it in term of sharpness ...
Ironically, if we compare to 35mm f/1.4 art that is seen as one of the best modern lens out there and we compare the 31mm at f/1.8 and the art f/2 on APSC bodies (the art with 24MP and the 31 with 16MP) we found slightly better center and slightly worse corners for the Art. Couting the added resolution for the Art test and the little less wide apperture (f/2 vs f/1.8) that pretty well show that the 31 doesn't need to fear anything, even for the most modern, most praised lenses.
And the comments from photozone:
"The FA 31mm f/1.8 Limited produced excellent resolution figures in the MTF lab. At f/1.8 the center performance is already very good both in the center as well at the borders. The corners are a bit softer here. The quality increases a bit when stopping down to f/2.8 with a center reaching excellent levels followed by very good borders and corners. The quality remains exceptionally high all the way down to f/11."
I admit I don't own the lens, but I seen many example here on the dedicated threads, looked at many example on the web and such, read many reviews... And I don't feel at all that FA31 is
weak sharpness wise at web resolution or is not "fully usefull". I see more that when you are at f/1.8 most of the subject is out of focus anyway, and that's not practical on most occasions except if you are after the effect. There also noticably less contrast and more aberations, but sharpness maintain a very good level. if one get a sample that weak at f/1.8 (like apparently the lenstip reviewer), the best is to get it serviced before the warrenty expire.
Last edited by Nicolas06; 11-23-2014 at 09:02 AM.