Originally posted by aleonx3 @mee, do you have both DA 50f1.8 and M 50f1.7? can you compare the front/rear glass elements of both to see if there is any noticeable size difference? I know it is more to it than that, but that would be something more readily identifiable if not at all.
That is an interesting idea.
Yes, I own both lenses. I put the rear glass 'back to back' and observed the DA's diameter is slightly less than the M's! Front element appears similar but that one is hard to check since the DA's design blocks checking. If I had a tape measure it would be far more accurate a test, but I do not have one of those (I have a lot of lenses but not a measly tape measure -- where is my priority here hehe).
That would probably answer why stevebrot is seeing vignetting at 1.8
That said I'd practically never use the DA50 f/1.8 lens at 1.8 anyways (even on a crop body) -- that lens shines stopped down to at least 2.8 (and further at 5.6 where it is incredibly incredibly sharp).